No texting, no calling, no posting, no scrolling, and no listening to music. Sounds like prison to middle schoolers and high schoolers in the state of Utah. Well because it is, with this new bell-to-bell policy that has been introduced into the schools. From the moment that they step into school they have no access to the digital world anymore until the day is over.
Some might see this new policy as good or exciting. But that might be because they think the effects of not having phones during the school day are actually beneficial. To enhance students educational and social interaction without the continuous use of electronic devices is the goal of this policy.
“I feel like that removal time is really beneficial to everybody,” said Steven Dunham, director of communications and foundation for Washington County school district. “You know, everybody talks about being unplugged. There needs to be time to be unplugged.”
Others though might see this as ridiculous and outrageous. Such as parents freaking out that they can not get into contact with their kiddos during the day or that they have a family emergency that needs attending. Or it could be a student not being able to connect with their friends, check team group chats, or just to be able to have their me time. Well, I am one of those others that think that this policy is ridiculous and outrageous.
This policy is very easy to understand but a lot harder to agree with. The facts are pretty simple and are laid out and said that every school in the state needs to enforce this bell-to-bell policy of the cellphone ban but it is up to the districts on how they implement it. For example, the Washington County school district are having grades kindergarten through ninth grade follow bell-to-bell but grades 10 through 12 are under more of a limited use policy.
During the school day students are required to keep their phones, AirPods, and any other electronic device you can think of except for smartwatches tucked away in their backpacks and to not be pulled out again until leaving. And, doing this for a seven hour school day sounds pretty insane and criminal if you were to ask me. If I had to do this, I would not be able to do my schoolwork, send emails, or communicate with my bosses and editors. Which in reality would turn into me falling behind, getting fired, or losing opportunities.
This policy has seen some benefits though. Even though the school districts are not tracking any true data which in all honesty is very confusing on why not. Because for them to truly tell if this policy is helping or hurting is to actually track things such as test scores or less instances of conflict, right? But they have been told by other indicators.
“We’re not specifically tracking data, but we are noticing fewer disruptions in the classrooms,” Dunham said. “I think it’s safe to say that we’re seeing less instances of bullying…And we’re seeing less instances of students feeling like they don’t fit in.”
These positive motions that the districts have been seeing are making this transition and process a lot easier on them.
Some of you still might be thinking why is this policy bad. Especially after hearing something like that. Like I mentioned earlier of what this policy would do to me and my life, I feel like some of the students also have the same concerns.
Even though I did not get my first phone until freshman year of high school, I still think of the many more things that I could have done and been a part of if I would have had a phone in middle school. The countless times I could have been sitting there playing Game Pigeon or Among Us with my friends after tests in class is too many times to count. All of that was because I did not even have a phone.
So in a way, I kind of have already experienced my own little self bell-to-bell policy thanks to my parents. It was not something that was fun or exciting to experience. It was actually more along the lines of gut wrenching pain and just sadness. And, knowing now that students will never even have that chance to play games on their phones after tests or assignments with their friends breaks a piece of my heart a little.
That being said, knowing that every bone of my body does not agree with this policy, hopefully the school districts and the people in charge one day figure out that the world is evolving daily. Cellphones and any other electronic devices are just going to keep being a part of our lives more and more as time goes on.










